Showing posts with label Caterpillars. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Caterpillars. Show all posts

October 12, 2013

A wonderful Bug Day

On September 7, I had the opportunity to participate as a volunteer in a "Bug Day", in the Fletcher Wildlife Garden. It was jointly sponsored by the Entomological Society of Ontario and the Ottawa Field-Naturalists' Club, and brilliantly organized by Sophie Cardinal, a bee researcher from the Canadian National Collection of Insects (Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada). The interested person can find more details of what happened that day and some photos here.

It was indeed a celebration of insects and Nature, with around one thousand participants attending and enjoying the many "attractions" that were prepared by the organizers. Tables were set up to showcase insect collections in drawers, living insects in cages, a fish tank with aquatic insects, cockroach races, nature walks (where collecting and later mounting of insects was taught), entomology-related crafts and face-painting, use of microscopes, exhibition of specimens used in actual biological control projects in Canada, and many more things. 

Among those tables there was one devoted to "Rearing Caterpillars", led by Chris Schmidt, a researcher on Lepidoptera working for the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. Chris had brought a number of caterpillars collected around Ottawa, including a few that could be touched by kids and adults. Over the four hours that the event ran, we talked to many persons interested in caterpillars and other aspects of Nature. We also enjoyed their faces when they examined some glass jars and tried to find larvae mimicking thin branches or bird droppings. It is this capacity to be surprised, while enjoying the new knowledge acquired, what makes so beautiful the study of the natural world. Especially for the small kids!

Chris Schmidt enjoying his talk with a family interested in caterpillars 
(Photo by Sophie Cardinal). 
 
I was fortunate to be there helping Chris, because I ended learning lots of things from his vast knowledge of local caterpillars -well, to be honest, his expertise goes way beyond local Lepidoptera. And it was also great to exchange from our different perspectives rearing caterpillars (Chris does it to get the adult moths and butterflies, while I do that to get their braconid parasitoid wasps). Two different worlds that nevertheless are deeply linked.

And, of course, I could not resist to bring some additional information... about those parasitoids. I printed a few images of parasitized caterpillars, and also wrote a small brochure on how to rear them -with the hope of attracting someone to this often-ignored task. It was great to find a few persons interested in such activities. At the end of the day I ran out of pictures and most of my brochures! 

Some images of caterpillars parasitized by microgastrine wasps 
(Images taken from Google Images).

Among people that impressed me the most were a couple of school teachers -both promised me that next spring they would try to get some students interested in rearing parasitoids from caterpillars... Hopefully I hear from then soon!

There was also a small kid who seemed to know very well the parasitoid wasps, and nicely explained to me the whole process of parasitism and emergence of the wasp larva from the caterpillar host ("How do you know that?", I asked him in awe, and he replied with ease "I found it in Wikipedia!". It was a wonderful experience). 
A simple explanation of what can be found when rearing caterpillars, part of the 
brochure on rearing caterpillars and parasitoids prepared for the Bug Day.
(Some images from Google Images, others taken by the author). 
 
And then there was another biologist, Alexander MacDonald, Manager of Protected Areas for Nature Canada. He was obviously very knowledgeable and interested, and got really excited with the idea of rearing parasitoids. We have kept corresponding since then, and I am delighted to see that collaborations can materialize in the most unexpected ways. 

At the end, this Bug Day was a great experience not only for those attending the event, but also for the volunteers. I do look forward to repeat the celebration the next year. And I certainly look forward to get involved with more citizens of Ottawa interested in rearing caterpillars parasitoids!

May 6, 2013

Importance of rearing caterpillars and its parasitoids

A month ago I had the great opportunity and honor of visiting Mark Shaw in Scotland, and Kees van Achterberg in the Netherlands. Today I will be writing about my stay with Mark, and what I learned from his extraordinary collection.

The first thing I realized was how few I know on parasitoid biology, especially compared to what Mark knows. It is a humbling experience to listen to him talking about particular species of wasps attacking particular species of caterpillars -and on determined plants, at different moments of the season/year! Here in North America we are light-years away of that kind of knowledge. By comparison, we know nothing.

Another thing I learned was to not be fooled by the appearances. Mark's collection (photos below) might seem a bit rustic... but make no mistake, you are contemplating one of the greatest resources available about biology and ecology of Lepidoptera-parasitoid wasps.
 

The collection -which in due time will be transferred to proper wooden drawers and deposited in the National Museums of Scotland, in Edinburgh- mostly comprises thousands of specimens collected by Mark during the last 2-3 decades. Decades he spent patiently rearing caterpillars, mostly in the United Kingdom, but also in many places across Europe. There are hundreds of new host records, and valuable ecological information on the wasps species, mostly Braconidae, but also Ichneumonidae and a few other families of Hymenoptera parasitoids.

During my 5-days visit I only had time to study 2 genera of Microgastrinae, and could not even finish with them. Going through the collection I was amazed to see the richness of the data gathered by Mark. And, as a greedy person gathering golden coins from a treasure coffin, I spent my last two days frantically recording data and typing notes in my laptop... 

March 14, 2013

The beautiful complexity of caterpillar-parasitoid food webs

This morning the good friend and colleague Dr. Jan Hrcek sent me a copy of his last paper on caterpillar-parasitoid food webs in Papua New Guinea (PNG). In the past we had collaborated regarding some work on braconid wasps, especially microgastrines. Jan has been researching caterpillars and their parasitoids in PNG for several years and has published quite a few interesting and amazing papers on the topic.

The title of the paper that he sent me today is "Parasitism rate, parasitoid community composition and host specificity on exposed and semi-concealed caterpillars from a tropical rainforest", and was published in Oecologia. It documents parasitism rate and host specificity in a highly diverse caterpillar-parasitoid food web encompassing 266 species of lepidopteran hosts and 172 species of hymenopteran or dipteran parasitoids from a lowland tropical forest in PNG.

I strongly recommend the reading of this paper -which, unfortunately, is not open access, but I guess the interested reader could contact Jan to ask for a copy. Anyone rearing caterpillars and/or dealing with caterpillar parasitoids will find the data reported there useful. I found the comparison between parasitoids of external and semi-concealed host very telling, even though some results are not in line with some preconceived ideas -such as ichneumonid wasps being more generalists than tachinid flies. But preconceived ideas are just that, and field data may change our "old thinking" on parasitoids. This study is based in collecting almost 40,000 caterpillars in the wild, with a rearing success of more than 11,000 adult Lepidopterans and over 1,500 parasitoids (wasps and flies) which represented 12% of parasitism rate. That is certainly a sizable database to extract some valid conclusions -although it may be risky to make generalizations to the world fauna based on only one study site, but I look at this as a very valuable piece of information.

And, of course, I liked the fact that braconids, and especially Microgastrinae, are considered the most suitable group for the biological control of caterpillars (but I am totally biased here ;-)

Most importantly, it is an eye-opener to realize that there has been no resarch like this in the past. Even the most comprehensive studies rearing caterpillars in several regions of the world -Jan cites in his paper a good number of such studies- have not fully addressed the potential differences between parasitoid communities of exposed and concealed (or semi-concealed) hosts. We still know so few about this and many other related topics!

After I read Jan's paper I went to briefly check some of those past researches that he mentioned. And I spent some time analyzing the diverse approaches, merits and/or shortcomings of those studies. There are many logistics difficulties, lack of resources and time constraints that limit what we can do -especially in tropical, hyperdiverse areas... I will try to cover those topics in future posts.

It is never a simple thing this endeavour of rearing caterpillars and study their parasitoids!

February 7, 2013

The taxonomic conundrum of Cotesia xylina and Cotesia yakutatensis

One of the main purposes of this blog is to provide comments on species of Microgastrinae that are of interest to a broader audience. I am still thinking on how to organize those posts to make them more useful to potential users, and hopefully soon will come with a system to do that. In the meantime, I am tagging them with the label "Species Profile", to make it easier to search and retrieve that kind of data.

Today I will briefly comment on two Nearctic species of Cotesia that present an interesting challenge to taxonomists and biocontrol workers alike: Cotesia xylina (Say, 1836) and C. yakutatensis (Ashmead, 1902).  Both species are only found in the Nearctic region, although yakutatensis has a wider and more northern range, extending up to Alaska in the West and up to Greenland in the East.
Distribution of Cotesia xylina and Cotesia yakutatensis. Data taken from Taxapad (2012). The coloured areas represent the Provinces/States where the species have been recorded, but no information on exact localities is shown here.

Both species have been reared from several species of Lepidoptera, mostly from the family Noctuidae, with some of the hosts representing agricultural pests. The validity of some records is questionable, especially the ones from Pyralidae and Sphingidae -those were reported in papers before 1920 (mostly late XIX century), and the wasps species may just have been missidentified.


C. xylina has been recorded parasitizing eight species of caterpillars: Epiglaea apiata, Mamestra configurata, Peridroma saucia, Xestia c-nigrum, Xylena nupera (all noctuids), Evergestis rimosalis (Pyralidae), Lampara bombycoides, and Smerinthus jamaicensis (Sphingidae). As written above, the last two records are suspicious.

As far as I know, there is no published paper providing illustrations or drawings of C. xylina, so here I present one colour photo taken a couple of years ago in the CNC.  

January 23, 2013

A braconid wasp in the COSEWIC List?

The Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada (COSEWIC) exists to provide Canadians and their governments with advice regarding the status of wildlife species that are nationally at risk of extinction or extirpation. Its committee of experts assesses and designates which wildlife species are in some danger of disappearing from the national territory. As part of  its work, COSEWIC produces a Candidate List of species. I strongly recommend to anyone interested in the protection of the Canadian nature to visit the COSEWIC website, and to support their work and that of similar organizations. [Disclaimer: I do not work for COSEWIC, nor I am involved with their efforts in any capacity].

My interest in COSEWIC, and the reason I am writing this post today is to discuss the POSSIBILITY of including a parasitoid Braconidae wasp within their list. Is that a real thing? Or am I just getting too excited with my subject of research?

Let's look at the facts and try to be impartial. COSEWIC List includes quite a few arthropods species. Which in itself is something truly amazing, especially in this world that usually focus its conservation efforts in large, charismatic fauna -conservation efforts also prioritize the flora, but I will leave plants out of this comment and will restrict myself to animals for the time being. 

Small animals, like insects, tend to be almost completely overlooked... unless they are "charismatic" by themselves, e.g. a beautiful butterfly, a conspicuous bumble bee, a colorful ground beetle, a large dragon fly, etc. But a small parasitoid wasp (2.5 mm long)... are you kidding me? Who cares about THAT?

Well, as they say "no harm in trying", and I am trying today to present the case for a first parasitoid wasp to be considered by COSEWIC: the microgastrine species Apanteles samarshalli Fernández-Triana, 2010.
The species was described very recently, in 2010, from specimens found mostly in southern Florida, United States (Everglades and the Florida Keys). I have also found additional specimens in two countries of Central America (data from unpublished studies). 

But, the original description also recorded the species from one Canadian locality: Rondeau Provincial Park, in southwestern Ontario. Rondeau truly honours its reputation of having species commonly found at much southern latitudes, because the single specimen collected there (in August of 1973, and deposited in the Canadian National Collection of Insects, Ottawa) happens to be, by far, the northernmost known for the species.

January 16, 2013

Open for business: Apanteles fumiferanae

The microgastrine wasp Apanteles fumiferanae Viereck is one the most important Braconidae -as forest pest management concerns- in North America. Based on specimens available in collections, it is the most common braconid parasitoid reared from the spruce budworm Choristoneura fumiferanae (Harris) (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae), which in turn is one of the major forest pests in the region.

Very few pests rival the spruce budworm in importance, and thus this lepidopteran species has been extensively studied over the years. There are hundreds of papers covering details of its biology, ecology, damage and control (biological, chemical, integrated). As part of those studies, for many years its caterpillars have been collected and reared for parasitoids, providing perhaps the best information ever available for a single forest pest in the Neartic. And still there are many details to be researched and understood!

Some recent papers summarize what we know until now. For example, an excellent analysis of the complex relationships between the spruce budworm and its parasitoids/hyperparasitoids/pathogens, was published by Eldon Eveleigh (Canadian Forest Service, CFS) and ten co-authors in 2007; it can be freely downloaded here. Reading that paper will open anyone eyes regarding the complexities of the food webs in a temperate forest. I especially recommend to check Figure 1 of that paper (which is not for the faint of heart!). One can only image similar analysis for a tropical forest... it is just mind boggling.

From a parasitoid perspective, John Huber, also from the CFS, led a team of four taxonomists to produce a series of papers covering all major groups of parasitoids of the genus Choristoneura in the Nearctic region: chalcid wasps (Huber, 1996), tachinid flies (O'Hara, 2005), ichneumonid wasps (Bennett, 2008) and braconid wasps (Fernández-Triana and Huber, 2010). Those works provided numerous illustrations, keys, and taxonomic notes to help identifying the large fauna of currently known parasitoids (230 species within 106 genera and 13 different families; see figures 155-157 and Discussion in Fernández-Triana and Huber (2010). [Unfortunately those papers can be downloaded for free, except for their Abstracts. However, being one of the authors of the braconid paper, I have plenty of reprints for that one, and would be pleased to send copies to anyone interested].

Which bring us back to the topic of this post: Apanteles fumiferanae. The species is widely distributed in the Nearctic region (there is also a record from Poland, but that might be incorrect). It has been reared from caterpillars of 17 lepidopteran species representing 4 families (although some of those early records, from historical references, are likely to be wrong). Close to one hundred scientific papers have dealt with that wasp species, and there is reason to believe more are needed... Why? Because A. fumiferanae actually comprises a complex of morphologically cryptic species (i.e. species that cannot be easily separate based on external morphology, yet are distinct biological entities).

December 16, 2012

Braconid wasps and forest pests in Canada

In a previous post, I analyzed some interesting data coming from the Canadian Forest Pest Management Forum. I could find at least 119 species within 20 families of caterpillars (Lepidoptera) that have been mentioned as pests of some kind to our forests in the past few years. As a taxonomist working with braconid wasps, my next logical step was then to see how many parasitoid species have been recorded out of those 119 lepidopterans.

For such a compilation I used the great resource that is Taxapad. [I have mentioned previously what Taxapad is, and promise that will dedicate a future post to that magnificent database maintained by Dicky Yu (Canada), Cornelis van Achterberg (The Netherlands) and Klaus Horstmann (Germany). Suffice to say for now that Taxapad should be considered as a key tool by many biologists and entomologists, especially those working in biocontrol].

Altogether, 299 species of Braconidae have been found, worldwide, attacking those pest caterpillars. I stress here the world "worldwide" in the sense that those records go beyond Canada to include ANY braconid wasp that has been cited in the scientific literature as a parasitoid of those lepidopterans. It is difficult and very time consuming to separate the sources of information for each individual species and pinpoint the country source. And it is even more difficult to be sure about the certainty of some of those records -some are likely to be wrong for a number of causes. Still, they give us a kind of ballpark estimate about the diversity of parasitoids of forest pest caterpillars. So, for the purpose of this post we can take the worldwide totals as a first approximation to the story of what is going on in Canada.

The first thing that becomes clear is how few we know about the parasitoid of those forest pests. Surely that 299 braconids sounds like an awfully large number of wasps, but the numbers are misleading (see the graph below). Because for 40 (33.6%) of those caterpillar species there is ZERO braconid wasps recorded as parasitoids. That means one third of the caterpillars where we know NOTHING of its parasitoid biology. For another 31 species of lepidopterans (26%) we only know one or two species of braconid parasitoids.



Braconidae species (299) recorded as parasitoids of 119 pests caterpillars of some relevance to Canadian forests. Data source mostly from Taxapad (2012). The numbers on top of each bar represent the actual number of braconids in each category.


On the other side of the spectrum, we have recorded 30 or more braconid parasitoids for 4 species of caterpillars. They represent important pests (such as the spruce budworm or the gipsy moth) which at some point have been the focus of serious rearing efforts from biocontrol workers, resulting in hundreds of research papers. If anything, that should be the example to follow with other pest species that are important as well. 

December 6, 2012

Forest Pest Management Forum

This week Ottawa hosted, once again, the Forest Pest Management Forum. This is an annual meeting where people from all over Canada (and a few from the United States) gather together to share updated information about forestry pests and its management in the country. 

I have never been to those meetings, but this year a good friend and colleague, Dr. John Huber, from the Canadian Forestry Service and the Canadian National Collection of Insects (CNC) in Ottawa, suggested me to attend. And I was seriously planning to go when some unexpected complications at work prevented me to do it. 

As a "consolation prize" I ended checking the website of the meeting to at least have a sense of what was going on there. First I found a nice compilation of pdf files with the proceedings of past meetings. Anyone interested in the topics of Entomology, Forestry and Pest Management should take the time and revise that valuable source of data. There are tons of information there. One of the most interesting, in my humble opinion, is to see the historical pattern of pests, within the country and in individual provinces. You can follow the evolution of different pest problems that Canadian forests have experienced during the past years by just reading those proceedings.

I went back only seven years, up to the proceedings of the 2005 meeting. But found quite a few interesting details, and this post is to share what I found about Lepidoptera pests.

First of all, I could compile a list of 119 species and 20 families of Lepidoptera caterpillars that have been considered forestry pests
in Canada (see detailed list at the end of this post).  Half of all species belong to just two families: Geometridae (27%) and Tortricidaae (26%), and seven families account for three quarters of the species.


Lepidoptera considered as pest of Canadian forests (grand total: 119 species and 20 families). For an explanation of the data sources, see detailed list of species added at the end of this post.

Of course, most of those species are of low significance and cause minor affectations to forestry (or the damage is just too sporadic or too sparse to consider them of real importance). Actually less than a dozen species can be considered as serious pests. Still, this grand total of 119 species should remind us of how quickly things can go wrong with an insect pest. Unfortunately, the next "new pest" outbreak might be just around the corner...

November 26, 2012

Why Microgastrinae and why they may interest you


When rearing caterpillars, it is common to find some small parasitoid wasps (1.5-8 mm long), often black or yellow and with rather short "abdomen". They belong to the subfamily Microgastrinae (Order Hymenoptera, Family Braconidae), and are one of the most important groups parasitizing butterflies and moths (Order Lepidoptera). These wasps are key components in the biological control of agriculture and forestry pests; and have also been extensively used in biodiversity, ecological, behavioral and molecular studies. However, its narrow host specificity and extraordinary diversity (more than 2,200 described species, with an estimate of 20-40,000 worldwide) presents an immense challenge. 
Addressing the need of more information about those fascinating insects is the main reason of this website. Tips to recognize different genera, species profiles, new biological data, distribution records, and other comments will be provided in following posts. Also, the readers are encouraged to send any question and/or contribution they may have about microgastrines (or any braconid wasp) parasitizing caterpillars. 

Detailed distribution of species and their host records will be compiled from different sources (mostly mined from the large and rich collection available in the Canadian National Collection of Insects, as well as other collections I have visited and/or borrowed material from). Contents intend to be useful to anyone already working or just interested in rearing caterpillars and their parasitoids. It will hopefully interest workers on biological control, bioinformatics, biodiversity researchers, wasp taxonomists, conservation authorities and entomological societies looking for information of species in particular areas. 



November 19, 2012

What do we know about the largest Apanteles species in North America?

In a previous post it was mentioned that the braconid wasps of the subfamily Microgastrinae comprise specimens ranging from 1.5 to 8.0 mm of body length. The truth is that most of the microgastrines are rather small, usually 2.0 to 3.5 mm long. The "record" of 8 mm is reserved for "giant" specimens of Larissimus, a tropical genus in South America. However, in North America there are very few species that surpass the 4 mm mark, and most of those species are in the genera Microgaster and Protomicroplitis...

Among the largest specimens of microgastrine wasps in North America, the species Apanteles crassicornis stands on its own with around 5 mm of length. That species is also noteworthy because of its elongate face and enlarged glossa, which is supposedly related to the gathering of pollen or nectar. 

Apanteles crassicornis (Provancher, 1866). Antennae and legs are missing some segments. Photo of the holotype of the species, deposited in Laval University, Quebec.

November 12, 2012

An overview of braconid wasps in Canada

Braconid wasps are the second largest group within Hymenoptera (the insect order that comprises bees, stinging wasps, ants, sawflies and parasitoid wasps). The last version of Taxapad records 956 described species of Braconidae for Canada. Of course, that is just the total of species that have been given scientific names by taxonomists. But it does not account for the many undescribed and/or unrecorded species that remain to be discovered. How many species are actually out there in the Great White North?  



Main subfamilies of Braconidae (Hymenoptera) in Canada. Total number of species: 956 [based on Taxapad (2012)].
While it is impossible to be certain, it is likely that at least twice the current figure, or about 2,000 species of braconid wasps will be found in Canada when all is said and done. 

Think about that for a second. The only group of living things (excluding perhaps microorganisms) that is more diverse than braconids wasps is yet another group of parasitoid wasps: Ichneumonidae, which happens to be the sister group to braconids. Ichneumonid wasps currently comprise almost 3,000 species in Canada (2,834, according to Taxapad). Nothing else comes even close to those figures -and the same situation is probably found in most other areas of the planet. We are talking here about the biodiversity heavy-weights.


Two thousand species of braconid wasps in Canada is a great number, and it amazes to think that we are still missing ONE THOUSAND species to be recorded -let alone studied in detail! The vast majority of those tiny wasps play a capital role in the natural regulation of herbivores -which might otherwise become pests of our crops and forests. Thus, this is not only a matter of scientific inquiry, but also a practical issue with economical implications.